top of page
  • Writer's pictureSimon Elkinson

Having a CIO on the Board Could Have Saved the Post Office

By Simon Elkinson, Director and Founder at Piccadilly One

In the recent scandal involving the Post Office, a lack of oversight and governance led to catastrophic results that could have been mitigated with proper technological guidance. The role of a Chief Information Officer (CIO) in such scenarios becomes crucial, as demonstrated by analysing the implications of having a CIO on the board to prevent such scandals from occurring. This blog delves into the importance of a CIO in the boardroom, especially in organisations dealing with vast amounts of sensitive data and complex operations like the Post Office.

Understanding the Post Office Scandal

The Post Office scandal shook the foundations of trust and integrity in a revered institution that serves millions of customers. At the heart of the issue was the flawed Horizon IT system, which caused financial discrepancies leading to severe consequences for hundreds of postmasters and mistresses who faced wrongful accusations of theft, fraud, and false accounting. The lack of proper governance and oversight mechanisms to address the inherent flaws in the system exacerbated the problem, ultimately resulting in a long and painful legal battle.

The Role of a CIO on the Board

A CIO, as a senior executive responsible for overseeing the information technology strategies and policies of an organisation, brings a unique perspective to the boardroom. By having a CIO on the board, organisations like the Post Office could have benefited from strategic guidance on technology investments, risk management, and ensuring the alignment of IT systems with the overall business objectives. The expertise of a CIO in navigating complex IT landscapes could have preempted the issues plaguing the Horizon system, saving the Post Office from the subsequent scandal and legal ramifications.

Key Benefits of Having a CIO on the Board

  • Technology Governance : A CIO ensures that technology initiatives align with the organisation's goals and that the risks associated with IT systems are adequately managed. This proactive approach can prevent situations like the Post Office scandal, where technological failures led to severe repercussions.

  • Data Security and Compliance : With cyber threats on the rise and data breaches becoming more prevalent, having a CIO on the board can significantly enhance an organisation's data security measures. By prioritising data protection and compliance, the CIO can help safeguard sensitive information and prevent potential regulatory violations.

  • Innovation and Digital Transformation : A CIO is instrumental in driving innovation and spearheading digital transformation initiatives within an organisation. By leveraging emerging technologies and optimising IT infrastructure, the CIO can improve operational efficiency and enhance customer experiences.

The Impact of CIO-Centric Governance

In hindsight, the absence of a CIO on the board of the Post Office during the Horizon debacle highlights the critical need for robust IT governance frameworks that prioritise technological expertise at the highest levels of decision-making. By integrating a CIO-centric governance model, organisations can proactively address IT challenges, mitigate risks, and capitalise on technological advancements to drive sustainable growth and success.

Looking Ahead: Lessons Learned

As organisations across industries navigate the complexities of digital transformation and technological advancements, the role of the CIO in corporate governance cannot be overstated. The Post Office scandal serves as a stark reminder of the repercussions of overlooking IT governance and the invaluable contributions a CIO can make in steering organisations towards a secure, innovative, and resilient future.

CIO Boardroom


In conclusion, the Post Office scandal underscores the critical importance of having a CIO on the board to prevent catastrophic IT failures and safeguard organisational integrity. By incorporating the expertise of a CIO in strategic decision-making processes, organisations can proactively address IT challenges, enhance cybersecurity measures, and leverage technology to achieve sustainable growth and success. The lessons learned from the Post Office scandal serve as a compelling case for embracing CIO-centric governance to navigate the evolving digital landscape with resilience and foresight.

Piccadilly One help organisations hire CIOs. We Put People Above Technology placing the number one technology position within an organisation and that person's direct reports.

To discuss your next CIO hire contact our Director and Founder Simon Elkinson

72 views0 comments


bottom of page